ZDNet UK


Skip to Main Content

ZDNet.co.uk - Winner of Best Business Website 2007
  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Blogs
  4. Reviews
  5. Prices
  6. Resources
  7. Community
  8. My ZDNet

 

ZDNet UK RSS Feeds


IT Jobs

Office applications Toolkit

Find it fast: desktop search programs

Robert Vamosi CNET

Published: 23 Mar 2005

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendly
  • Post Comment

There's a hot new battle emerging between Google, Yahoo and Microsoft over localised (or desktop) search -- that is, finding specific files on your hard drive. If you're like most people, you stuff your hard drive with more digital photos and ripped music files every day. Maybe you toss them willy-nilly into your My Documents folder in Windows, or -- if you're really organised -- you slip them into My Music or My Photos. If you're in business, you probably also pack away documents and correspondence that, if lost, could cost you time and money to recover.

But while it's handy keep all of your files on your PC's hard drive, it's not quite so simple to find a specific one in the jumble. Before you know it, your PC has turned into a black hole where all important information goes to die. That's why, right now, a handful of companies are fighting to build the holy grail of desktop search: a program that will quickly and easily find your files no matter where you stashed them. Like search engines that scour the Internet and produce results in seconds, these new hard drive versions can instantly pull up references to files based on keywords, file types or designated folders. For example, these programs can hunt down your holiday photos as long as they have something searchable, such as the words 'summer 2004', somewhere in their name.

But not all of these desktop search engines are alike. We looked at eight, including Lookout, which was recently purchased by Microsoft. Search engine leader Google has released a beta of its own search engine tool and Microsoft has recently entered the fray, while AOL is expected to do so shortly. Some search only email correspondence, while others can find almost any file on your hard drive and also search the Internet. Some index your drive as you use it, constantly updating tables of data so that the search results are produced quickly. Others index on the fly, taking perhaps a few more seconds to produce specific results, but requiring less system resources. Most are free; one, X1, is not. Read our reviews for help in choosing the hard drive detective to dig out your data.

Desktop search programs compared


Blinkx




Copernic
Desktop
Search


Google
Desktop
Search (Beta)

HotBot




MSN
Desktop
Search


Lookout




X1 Search



Yahoo
Desktop
Search (beta)


Editors' Rating 7.0 8.3 n/a 6.6 7.0 7.6 8.0 n/a
Works within Outlook no no no no yes yes no yes
Works within Internet Explorer no no yes yes yes no no yes
Works standalone yes yes no no no no yes no
Indexes email yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
File viewer limited some files no no no no yes yes
RSS yes no no yes no no no no
Indexes contents of attached files in email limited yes yes no no no yes yes
Price free free free free free free $75 (~£42) free

Related articles

Google Desktop Search Beta

Preview Google has joined the burgeoning desktop search market with a public beta. We've had a day or so to play with it -- here's our initial report. [15 Oct 2004]

12 Talkbacks


Yahoo Desktop Search (beta)

Preview Although it's still in public beta, we have great expectations for Yahoo Desktop Search, and we like the features we've seen so far. [23 Mar 2005]


  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendly Print with HP
Compare The Products Product Date Editors'
Rating
Readers'
Rating
Compare The Products Product Date Editors'
Rating
Readers'
Rating

Did you find this article useful?
64 out of 120 people found this useful


Vista Upgrade Blog

Windows Driver Updates

Because of my recent adventures with Windows Vista on my Lifebook, I've had to learn about and deal with the differences between Vista and XP in third-party device driver distribution... More

2 comments

Windows XP SP3 Installed

I have downloaded and installed Service Pack 3 for Windows XP Professional on my Fujitsu Lifebook S6510. Everything went smoothly, and it seems to work just fine. I don't see anything... More

Post a comment

Vista vs. XP: The Final Retreat

I suppose that most people are getting tired of reading about Vista vs. XP. I know that I am getting tired of writing about. I'm getting even more tired of fighting with it. So this... More

Post a comment

Discussions

barrie barrie

Windows Driver Updates

Friday 16 May 2008, 3:14 AM

2 comments
jgj jgj

"what more do you need?"

Thursday 15 May 2008, 9:19 PM

5 comments
jgj jgj

"what more do you need?"

Thursday 15 May 2008, 9:19 PM

5 comments
dwr50 dwr50

Just tried it...

Thursday 15 May 2008, 9:12 PM

2 comments

Featured Talkback

"We don't recommend specific technologies — we promote the use of technology per se." What sort of nonsense is this?? Every Becta endorsed IT supplier to schools is a Microsoft shop. Every single one.

By: 1000193068

Read full story:
Becta takes Microsoft to the OFT