PDA prizefight: Palm OS 5 v Windows Mobile 2003
Published: 26 Feb 2004
And the winner is…
Any handheld you buy today is guaranteed to be powerful, practical, and more capable than a mid-'90s desktop system. In many respects, the playing field is level, regardless of which platform you choose.

That said, although Windows Mobile 2003 is the superior operating system when it comes to data entry and multimedia, Palm OS 5 offers easier operation, more third-party software, better desktop compatibility, and a stronger email application (even if it's not standard to the OS). As for Microsoft Office compatibility and core applications, the two operating systems are evenly matched.
In the end, Palm OS is the champ for now. But we're keeping an eye out for Windows Mobile 2004 and the new Palm OS Cobalt (formerly known as Palm OS 6). Maybe a rematch next year?
Full Talkback thread
25 comments
-
Nice try to award Palm OS 5 as the winner! I disag... JED -
First of all, the difficulty you describe in openi... Steve Hall -
At a time when PDAs are used for more than just ha... Anonymous -
I have used to both the Pocket PC and Palm systems... Anonymous -
In using both the pocket PC and Palm for a long ti... Bill Ayers -
I used the Palm OS for six years and loved it. I... Paul Alandt -
I disagree as well with the direction this article... Anonymous -
Actually, they *did* compare the two fairly a... Verne Arase -
absolutely agree with the article. being a user of... David T -
The PDA market is losing out to smartphones. It wo... shekhar -
Given a choice, I will opt for Palm just simply I... Michael Lee -
i think pocket pc is better than palm os ,especial... hock lam lee -
You seem to be comparing the Pocket PC out of the... Peter Freeth -
I notice reading previous comments that opini... Denis -
If you want a paper weight, or at least to blow so... James E. Freedle II -
I recently purchased a PDA. Before doing doing tha... Nightz -
Windows Explorer makes Windows Mobile the winner i... Erik -
I was genuinely pleased with my Palm PDA - Sony Cl... Anonymous -
Not only does this article not compare like with l... Anon -
I think the article is rather good, no favorites a... Marijan Franovic -
After looking carefully at current PDAs I bought a... Duncan Corps -
Its been 2 years since the day i had my first PDA... strayato hirzaki -
And this is not an OS comparison I think. What abo... Michael Elfial -
I owned an IPAQ for a year and it was replaced 3 t... Monty Green -
hmm i'm stuck, i have had my IPAQ 1940 for ne... Anonymous
New Products
Acrobat 9 Pro Extended: a first look
Adobe's Acrobat 9 document-creation software is adding dynamic features such as animation integration, dynamic maps, 256-bit encryption and improved forms.
What we know about Windows 7
Microsoft is remaining tight-lipped about the next version of Windows, due in late 2009 or early 2010: ZDNet.com's Redmond-watcher Mary Jo Foley summarises what we do know.
SQL Server 2008: a first look
Microsoft has made some big promises for SQL Server 2008, a major update of its enterprise database product. Here's an outline of the key new features.
Internet Explorer 8 beta: a first look
Can the latest version of Internet Explorer arrest its declining market share? We examine the first beta of IE8.
Featured Talkback
So if you upgrade to XP SP3 you can't uninstall Internet Explorer, I'm quite sure I'm having a Deja-vu feeling about MS preventing people from uninstalling Internet Explorer in other Windows products.
By: TheKLF99
Read full story:
Upgraders to XP SP3 warned over IE downgrades
Test Your Desktop Management Systems
How good are your company's desktop management solutions? How do they compare with those of your peers?
Take two minutes to complete our new Desktop Management and Energy Consumption benchmark, and find out what issues your business needs to focus on.
Skip Sub Navigation Links to CNET Brand Links
- Security threats
- Mobile devices
- Application development
- Network management
- Desktop platforms
- Security management
- Databases
- Processors
- Server platforms
- Storage
- Mobile working
- Office applications
- After hours
- Mail & messaging
- Training
- Disaster recovery
- Enterprise applications
- VoIP
- Emerging tech
- Green IT
- Outsourcing
- Virtualisation
- SME
- Enterprise open source
- Industry watch
- Online business
- Accessibility
- Management
- Intellectual property
- Compliance
Home
- Site Map
- RSS Feeds
- Content Archive
- ZDNet.co.uk Mobile
- Search Library
Membership
- Log in
- Register
- Membership benefits
- Community FAQs
- Newsletters
About Us
- Contact Us
- Find Us
- Privacy Policy
- Permissions and Reprints
- International
- Advertise
News
- Hardware News
- Software News
- Communications News
- Internet News
- Security News
- IT Management News
- Emerging Technology News
- Leaders
Blogs
Group Blogs
- News blog
- Reviews blog
- Not Safe For Work blog
- Rupert's Diary blog
- Sentry Posts blog
- Vista Upgrade blog
- On The Road blog
- Homebrew blog
- Post Room blog
- Uptime blog
ZDNet UK Staff Blogs
- Matt Loney
- Rupert Goodwins
- Charles McLellan
- Andrew Donoghue
- David Meyer
- Tom Espiner
- Colin Barker
- Karen Friar
Core Techs Expert Blogs
- Adrian Bridgwater
- Peter Judge
- Christian Harris
Tech Community
- Top 100 ZDNet UK Members
- My ZDNet Tour
- Forums
- Competitions
- Community FAQs
Benchmarks
- Business Value benchmark
- Server Value benchmark
- Desktop Management benchmark
- Mobile Security benchmark
White Papers
- Most Popular white papers
Free Software Downloads
- Windows downloads
- Mac downloads
- Mobile downloads
Reviews
Hardware reviews
- Accessory reviews
- Audio reviews
- Component reviews
- Desktop reviews
- Handheld reviews
- Imaging reviews
- Input Device reviews
- Mobile Phone reviews
- Monitor reviews
- Networking reviews
- Notebook reviews
- Printer reviews
- Projector reviews
- Server reviews
- Storage reviews
Software reviews
- Content Creation reviews
- Developer Tool reviews
- Enterprise Application reviews
- Operating System reviews
- Productivity software reviews
- Security reviews
- Utility reviews
- Editor's Choice reviews
- Buyer's Guides
- Tech Guides
Tech Resources
- Company Pages
- Technology Events
- Research Panel
- Tech Jobs
Articles
- Case Studies
- Comment
- FAQs Articles
- Features
- Image Galleries
- Tutorials
- Video stories
- Research
Compare Prices
- Laptop prices
- Cheap Laptops
- Desktop prices
- Mac laptop prices
- Mac desktop prices
- Tablet PCs prices
- PDA prices
- Printer prices
- Printer cartridges prices
- Scanner prices
- Monitor prices
- Windows oftware prices
- Server prices
Special Features
- Broadband Speed Test
- CIO Vision Series
- Dialogue Box
















