ZDNet UK


Skip to Main Content

ZDNet.co.uk - Winner of Best Business Website 2007
  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Blogs
  4. Reviews
  5. Jobs
  6. Resources
  7. Community
  8. My ZDNet

 

ZDNet UK RSS Feeds


Join ZDNet's roundtable on datacentres

NETWORKING REVIEW

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print

SurfControl RiskFilter E-mail E10 review

6.5

Editors' Rating

Good

Design 6.0
Features 8.0
Setup & ease of use 5.0
Performance 7.0
SurfControl RiskFilter E-mail E10

Alan Stevens ZDNet.co.uk

Published: 12 Nov 2004

SurfControl is a well-established provider of software-based Web and email filtering tools, and the RiskFilter E-mail is the company's first stab at an appliance product. It’s a 1U rack-mount solution, based on an industry-standard Pentium 4 server, running a pre-configured, security hardened, Linux. This, in turn, hosts the SurfControl email antivirus, anti-spam and content filtering tools with a browser-based GUI for management. The RiskFilter E-mail E10 costs £8,500 (ex. VAT) for up to 500 users.

To install the RiskFilter you have to assign it a name and IP address using a local terminal, and then activate the software licence via the browser-based GUI. You then need to tell the RiskFilter software about your mail server(s). Here the SurfControl appliance acts as a message transfer agent, intercepting incoming messages for one or more domains or given IP addresses, filtering them, and then relaying those that pass onto the appropriate mail servers. This routing can be managed via DNS or by specifying the target servers manually, depending on the number involved.

Outgoing mail can also be filtered for viruses and spam, and disclaimers added if required. The RiskFilter can also be configured as a secure proxy for POP3, IMAP and HTTP client mail access. As with many mail server security appliances, it can be used with any SMTP mail host.

The SurfControl GUI is quite easy to master and, with ready configured default policies included, the RiskFilter appliance can be up and working in just a few minutes. McAfee-based antivirus scanning is turned on for all users; spam trapping, similarly, is enabled out of the box. Both of these facilities can be tuned, if necessary, and custom filtering policies set up to specify things like the level of spam detection to apply and what to do with messages trapped by the virus and spam filters.

There are facilities to either drop or quarantine suspect mail and modify headers and subject lines. Attachments can also be stripped. Usefully, users can be allowed to manage their spam directly, either deleting or releasing quarantined messages when notified via an email list containing the necessary links.

Other useful options include user-managed black/white lists and controls over message size and volumes per connection. There are also facilities to protect against Denial of Service (DoS) and directory attacks while to monitor activity there’s a built-in 'dashboard' display supported by a comprehensive set of reporting modules. These provide good basic summary information, although we'd have liked more information as to exactly why some messages had been blocked to help avoid false positives.

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendly
  • Post Comment

Rate this product

Member Opinion

8.9

Average Member Rating

Excellent

4 Members have reviewed this product

View Opinions by: Date Posted | Rating | Most Useful

Anonymous

Anonymous

SurfControl excels again

Read more

10

Perfect


Anonymous

Anonymous

A superb piece of kit -- buy it!

Read more

10

Perfect


Anonymous

Anonymous

Good product, rough edges

Read more

7.5

Very Good


Anonymous

Anonymous

Good product

Read more

8.0

Excellent


Read all the member opinions

Overview

SurfControl RiskFilter E-mail E10

Editors rating
Rating: 6.5
Verdict

This is a good first attempt at a mail server security appliance, but it needs more development to challenge the longer-established vendors.

Typical price

£ 8500

Sentry Posts Blog

Nasa and the virus

Yesterday the BBC ran a story about a computer virus making it into orbit, which I read with incredulity. OK, it's a nice silly season story on the surface, but what really got me was... More

3 comments

Customer data found on eBay server hig...

The recent news about customer details being retrieved from a server sold on eBay is yet another story about the sorry state of information security in the electronic age (see: http://news.zdnet.co.uk/...m).... More

Post a comment

Does it matter if you are an aardvark...

In spam terms, apparently it does. According to Cambridge University security expert Richard Clayton, if your email address is aardvark at animal.net, you are more likely to receive... More

5 comments