Advertisement
Promo

Processors Toolkit

Dual core shoot-out: Intel versus AMD

Kai Schmerer ZDNet Germany

Published: 03 Nov 2005

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendly
  • Post Comment

Application performance

The Business Winstone and Content Creation Winstone benchmarks carry out typical application-based tasks such as converting video files or creating a PowerPoint presentation. The following applications are used:

Content Creation Winstone 2004 (at 1600 by 1200 resolution)

  • Adobe Photoshop 7.0.1
  • Adobe Premiere 6.50
  • Macromedia Director MX 9.0
  • Macromedia Dreamweaver MX 6.1
  • Microsoft Windows Media Encoder 9.0
  • Internet Explorer
  • Newtek Lightwave 7.5b
  • Steinberg Wavelab 4.0f

Business Winstone 2004 (at 1600 by 1200 resolution)

  • 5 Microsoft Office XP applications (Access, Excel, FrontPage, PowerPoint, Word)
  • Microsoft Project 2002
  • Microsoft Outlook
  • Winzip 8.1
  • Norton Anti-Virus 2003
  • Internet Explorer

Business Winstone 2004 has two modes. In the standard test, there is no multitasking: several applications are loaded in memory, but only the foreground application is active. This corresponds to the work routine of a Web designer, for example, who first prepares graphical elements in Photoshop and then integrates them into a Web site using Dreamweaver.

There is also a multitasking mode in Business Winstone 2004 (BWS-MT Overall), in which the background applications are active. Business Winstone 2004 can also simulate different multitasking scenarios (BWS-MT Test 1, 2 and 3).

In the first scenario (BWS-MT Test 1) files are copied in the background, while Outlook and Internet Explorer process tasks in the foreground. The second scenario (BWS-MT Test 2) starts with Word and Excel in the foreground with Winzip files being compressed in the background. The third scenario (BWS-MT Test 2) runs a Norton Anti-Virus scan in the background, while all of the Microsoft Office programs are busy with tasks in the foreground.

Under Business Winstone 2004 (BWS04), the AMD processors are clearly the superior performers. Only in the multitasking test can Intel's chips keep up with their AMD counterparts.

Content Creation Winstone 2004 (CCWS04) lacks a multitasking mode, but many of the component programs in this benchmark are multithreaded. The AMD processors are the winners here, too. Even the entry-level $328 Athlon 64 X2 3800+ is faster than Intel's $999 Pentium EE 840.

It's worth noting that Intel's processors perform better under BAPCo's SYSmark thanks to its greater prevalence of Pentium 4-optimised applications. Ideally, a performance test should go beyond standard benchmark suites, and in the following pages we test AMD's and Intel's dual core chips with current applications from the audio, video and 3D-rendering markets.

Dual core processors are not particularly relevant to 3D gaming -- highly clocked single core processors such as the Athlon 64 FX57 or Pentium 4 670 are more suitable for this market. As a result, we have only tested with one game, Farcry, here: once again, the AMD chips deliver the best performance.

Business and Content Creation Winstone 2004 (bigger is better)

CPU Athlon 64 X2 Athlon 64 X2 Pentium D Pentium EE

Model number 3800+ 4800+ 820 840
CCWS04 37.7 40.7 29.8 33.4
BWS04 26.4 29.0 22.7 24.7
BWS-MT Overall 3.23 3.51 3.06 3.14
BWS-MT Test 1 2.55 2.56 2.72 2.89
BWS-MT Test 2 2.68 2.69 2.39 2.48
BWS-MT Test 3 3.96 4.75 3.56 3.58
Farcry Regulator (640) 141.9fps 169.6fps 120.4fps 130.0fps
















 

  • Email
  • Trackback
  • Clip Link
  • Print friendlyPrint with EPSON

Did you find this article useful?
652 out of 913 people found this useful


New Products

iPhone 3G S: a first look

iPhone 3G S: a first look

Apple's third-generation iPhone will be available on 19 June. Here are the highlights from its unveiling at the WWDC 2009 keynote.

Dell Adamo: a first look

Dell Adamo: a first look

Dell's much-anticipated Adamo, a high-end 'luxury' notebook, has finally been announced. Here's a hands-on look at a pre-production version.

Palm Pre: a first look

Palm Pre: a first look

Palm's new Pre smartphone and WebOS operating system have caused a stir at CES. Here are some first impressions of a platform that could revive the company's fortunes.

View all Previews

Video icon

Video

Discussions

roxyrohit roxyrohit

reply

Saturday 7 November 2009, 6:35 PM

37 comments
roxyrohit roxyrohit

reply

Saturday 7 November 2009, 6:35 PM

37 comments
roxyrohit roxyrohit

reply

Saturday 7 November 2009, 6:35 PM

37 comments
roxyrohit roxyrohit

reply

Saturday 7 November 2009, 6:34 PM

37 comments

Skip Sub Navigation Links to CNET Brand Links

Help

Become part of the ZDNet community.

Newsletters