Power consumption was measured using a Voltcraft Plus Digital Multimeter VC-940, obtained from Conrad.com. With the optional USB adapter and recording software, the data stream from the multimeter can be captured on a PC and saved in Excel format for further analysis.
The Voltcraft VC-940 digital multimeter, which we used to measure power consumption. Here, it's measuring the power drawn by an OLPC XO (with 100 percent screen brightness and with the battery charging) and delivering a data stream over USB to recording software on a Toshiba notebook.
Typical workload test Our main benchmark was a typical workload test — 'typical' in this context meaning relatively low-end tasks using mainstream productivity applications that are likely to be undertaken routinely by shoolchildren in developing countries.
To this end, the test involved (1) typing a short (187-word) document into a word processor, (2) entering three columns of figures into a spreadsheet and creating a graph, (3) opening a browser and using Google to find the Computer Aid web site and then open it, and (4) going to YouTube and playing a video showing Nelson Mandela talking about the meaning of the word Ubuntu. From the resulting data stream, we extracted the following measurements: power draw when idle (at the OS desktop); average power draw during the workload test; peak power; time taken to complete the workload test; and total power consumed during the workload test (in watt-hours).
Output from the Voltcraft VC-940 digital multimeter for the Inveneo Computing Station running our workload test, under Windows XP (blue line) and Linux (red line).
The workload test was performed by a human rather than run from an automated script, so the time taken to complete the test is not purely a measure of system performance. However, we used the same human operator (CM), and on the systems where we performed repeat tests, we got a variability of around 7 percent on average.
Other measurements we recorded separately were standby power (with the computer plugged in but turned off), boot-up time (to the OS desktop) and browser launch time (to Google, set as the home page). Finally, for the three notebooks in the test, we recorded battery rundown and recharge times.
We examine a number of low-power desktops, thin clients and notebooks to find out which platforms are most suitable for deployment in developing countries... more
The Aleutia E1 is a creditable effort at creating a compact, low-power desktop computer. However, the current hardware platform seems a little underpowered for anything other than the most basic tasks... more
The Inveneo Computing Station delivers reasonably good performance for a low-power PC. It's small, but an untidy assembly means it could be more convenient to handle... more
NComputing's L230 thin client is an option if you need to add a group of low-impact users to an existing Ethernet LAN. However, you'll need to ensure that the host PC is adequately specified to deliver acceptable performance to the terminals attached to it... more
NComputing's X300 provides a cost-effective way to hang up to six terminals off a single desktop PC using low-power, secure, easy to administer and quiet access terminals. It's not for power users, but is well suited to schools, business workgroups, libraries, internet cafés and suchlike... more
The Asus Eee PC 701 is a great notebook. It's extremely affordable, attractively designed and highly portable. If you're looking for an ultraportable travelling companion or a cheap second computer, there are few better options... more
Aimed at students in developing countries, the Intel Classmate PC is an intriguing attempt at a low-cost notebook. We love the rugged design, but the small 2GB solid-state hard drive doesn't leave a lot of room for growth... more
A work in progress rather than a finished product, the XO has much to recommend it. However, there are substantive issues to address if it's to live up to its creators' lofty ideals in practice... more
The MacBook Air is not quite an ultraportable, but it is exceptionally thin. Retaining the same 13.3in. display as the current MacBook line, it tapers from 1.94cm thick to just 0.4cm. Apple calls it the 'world's thinnest notebook'.
The Time Capsule's hybrid 802.11n wireless router/networked hard drive offers some powerful data-backup features for Mac owners, as well as Apple's typically pleasing design